Header

In This Site


View of Connemara Harbour

Big-Y SNP Testing

Back in November 2013, FTDNA announced the release of their NGS (Next Generation Sequencing) SNP test.

This test reads some 11 - 13 million bases along the Y chromosome and checks the result at some 35,000 known SNPs and in doing so, also potentially finds many new SNPs that would indicate branches in the Y-tree.

As at 05 November 2016, 54 members of the Irish Type III haplogroup have ordered an NGS test and 54 sets of results are available for analysis, including a set of results from another NGS laboratory, Full Genomes Corporation.

As with any other DNA test, you have to have other results to compare with and so with this test.

We have found that there are 19 additional reliable SNPs that we all have in common with L226, the SNP that was found to define the Irish Type III cluster in 2009.

We have no way of knowing the order of the appearance of each of these SNPs, that is if any or all of these SNPs originated before or after L226. As at March 2017 with 60 R-L226 sets of results, this group is still intact with no one having some but not all of the 20 SNPs in total, however further testing by other L226 men may reveal more in the future.

There have been many SNPs that have been found during Big-Y testing, that reveal branching under L226.

Here is the link to our Big-Y spreadsheet detailing our Big-Y analysis and showing the branching as described below.

Tree Tree

As you can see there are now some 40 branches discovered under L226 together with many 'private' branches (in pale blue). While they can all be seen in Big-Y results, some cannot be tested by conventional Sanger testing methods.

FTDNA has launched a SNP Pack available to test that includes all SNPs from the branches listed here, and many of the 'private' SNPs, 119 in total. It is called the R1b - L226 SNP Pack and is priced at $119.

If you can't afford the cost of Big-Y, then I do suggest that you take a R1b-L226 SNP pack test at FTDNA, which will likely show which terminal SNP you have.

What do we learn from Big-Y?

As well as the 20 SNPs in common and the many new branching SNPs, for each man tested, several 'private' SNPs have been found, ranging up to 21 in number. Whether these remain 'private', that is pertain to the last few generations of that participant's ancestry, or occurred further back will be revealed as more Irish Type III men test, and some of these 'private' SNPs have already been found to be 'branches' in the Irish Type III tree.

When we count up and average the SNPs that have occurred in these men since the 'bottleneck' event, that is ignoring the 19 SNPs that are equivalent to L226, we find it averages 13.88 new SNPs. When divided into the 1,450 years to the MRCA we get a figure of 105 years per SNP. If we use the same 105 years/SNP and multiply by the 20 phytogenetically equivalent SNPs we get a figure of 2,100 years, meaning that Irish Type III branched from the main R-Tree, under Z2534 (1,450 - 1,750 BC).

We have always wondered why the Irish Type III STR signature was so unique and unrelated to all other haplogroups. The fact that we have 20 reliable SNPs in common indicates a long stem with no branching back to the place where Irish Type III left the Y-tree and 2,100 years is certainly plenty of time for this haplogroup to develop such a distinctive STR signature.

Whether this origin occurred in Ireland or somewhere else we are yet to discover.

As we know that Sir Conor O'Brien, Chief of the Clan is on the Y6913 branch, and as we know that King Brian Boru was born in 943AD, everyone with the SNP FGC5659, (which seems to have originated in Brian or his father), and all branches below FGC5659, are likely to be direct descendants of this revered High King of Ireland.

If you have the funds, may I recommend Big-Y testing at FTDNA, which is usually $595, but sometimes on sale for $100 less, and if not then testing the FTDNA R1b-L226 SNP Pack will add to our knowledge of the 'Irish Type III' cluster. I recommend them to you.

Presentation on Big-Y to Genetic Genealogy Ireland 2016 conference

I was asked to make a presentation at the Genetic Genealogy Ireland 2016 conference in Dublin, Ireland over the weekend, 21-23 October 2016 on what we have learnt from Big-Y testing.

Here is a link to that presentation:- Click Here